Best Pizza Stone Reviews

When was the last time you wanted to make a pizza but didn’t really want to do it in a traditional pizza pan? You don’t get quite the same flavor or the same outcome when you make your pizza in a pan and especially not from a pizza that you’re making out a box.

That’s why the perfect pizza stone is going to be essential to getting just what you’re looking for from your pizza.

Missy Enders, Author, HESCA
Missy Enders

#1 Old Stone Oven

View On Amazon


This pizza stone is actually quite large with a rectangular design that is 14.5″ x 16.5″ to ensure you get a high quality pizza that is large enough to feed your entire family all at the same time. The stone is made to create just the type of pizza you’re looking for with the perfect balance between a chewy crust and a crunchy one.

The rectangular surface is enough for not only setting the pizza when it’s done and ready to cook, but also for making the pizza itself. You can lay out the dough and start adding all of your favorite toppings and other ingredients so it’s perfect and ready to be slid right into your oven or into your pizza oven as well.

There’s a specially made Heat Core inside the stone that ensures you crust is going to be crispy all the way through, without having to worry about the heat not getting to the center or not giving you exactly the same result all the way through.

What’s even better is this stone is designed for any type of heat and any volume of heat. You won’t have to worry about the oven getting too hot and your stone getting cracked, chipped or completely broken. You don’t even need to worry about temperature changes because it’s able to withstand large changes without any damage as well.

  • Made in the United States, this stone is designed to create layers in your pizza crust or even in your bread to make sure that it really give you everything you’ve been looking for and then some. You’ll absolutely love the results that you get and how fast you’re going to get them too because this is a top notch stone.

#2 Heritage Ceramic

View On Amazon


Perfectly designed for your favorite round pizza, this Heritage stone is 15 inches around and has a black color and ceramic styling that is designed to get you a high quality pizza without all the hard work on your part. With ceramic as your stone of choice you’re going to get the same quality but you’re going to get additional features you’re going to love.

The best thing with this stone is that it’s going to heat up a whole lot faster than any stone you’ve had before, up to 50% faster, and that means you’re going to be making your pizzas and eating your pizzas when you’re hungry instead of having to wait far too long for your stone to heat up and then for your pizza to be done.

The design also ensures that your pizza is going to cook evenly all the way through and all the way around, without having to worry about hot or cold spots while you’re cooking. Plus you don’t have to worry about any kind of odor because the ceramic doesn’t absorb anything. You can cook your pizza on it without any concern for what might happen.

Ceramic also doesn’t stain like other materials and that means you will have no problem getting your stone completely clean when you’re done making your pizza and you can rest assured that it will be clean and ready the next time you want to make one too.

  • Guaranteed to last for a lifetime, this stone is guaranteed also not to crack in your oven, no matter what temperature you decide to cook your pizza at. You’ll have a high quality pizza and your stone is going to be ready for the next time without any cracks, chips or other damage, so there’s nothing to worry about.

#3 Nordic Ware Pizza Stone Set

View On Amazon


This Nordic Ware Pizza Stone Set is going to give you all of the quality and taste of a brick oven pizza without actually needing the brick oven to cook it in. All you need to do is take out this 13 inch round stone and lay out your pizza. Then stick it in your oven and get a crispy and delicious dinner for the entire family.

The thick stone is able to absorb just the right amount of heat so you can be sure that you’re going to have quality and it’s going to deliver that heat through the food at just the right level of balance. That way you get a crispy pizza but not an overdone one. You also can be sure that you’re not going to have soggy or uncooked sections because the stone makes sure all heat is evenly distributed.

The 10 year warranty on this unit says that Nordic Ware definitely knows and trusts that it’s going to last for you and that it’s going to provide you with the kind of pizza you’ve been wanting instead of the pizza you’ve been settling for all of these years. Even better, it comes with everything you need to enjoy your next dinner.

This tool comes with not only the pizza stone for you to cook on, but also a rack so you can have the stone right there when you’re serving. You’ll also get a small pizza cutter that makes it so much easier to get everyone eating at the same time. With this set you’re going to have pizza a whole lot more often.

  • Make sure you’re getting this stone in order to try out your favorite pizzas again. Even the store bought ones are going to taste great with this stone in your arsenal.

Pizza Stone Buyer’s Guide


Take a look at the different sizes of pizza stones that are available and think about what your family really likes to eat. You can get small pizza stones that will help you make a personal pizza or a slightly larger than personal pizza. You can also get oversized stones that will help you make a large enough pizza for several people at the same time. You are the only one who can really decide what the perfect size is and it’s going to be up to you to figure out how many you’re going to need as well, since you might need more than one pizza when everyone realizes how great this one tastes.


There are many different shapes available for pizza stones as well. You’ll find that most of them are circular, but a number of them are going to be rectangular or square as well. This allows you to get the right style of pizza for your family. If some people like crust and some don’t then a square pizza stone might be the best option. If all of you are going to be fighting over the crust however, you might want to opt for a round pan or a small square one. The shape is definitely not going to change the great quality of the pizza you end up with though.


Traditional pizza stones are made with clay and stone to ensure you get the right crispness in your pizza. More modern stones are actually not made with stone at all, however, and actually use cast iron or even steel and other metals. These types of pizza are going to be easier to cook with and they’re going to get your pizza more evenly and quickly cooked. You’re not going to have the same type of movement however as these stones are definitely a lot heavier and harder to use.


You want to check out some more about preheating your stones as well. More sturdy and thick stones are going to require even more preheating because you’re going to have to get the stone hot enough that your pizza will start to cook right away. This could be up to half an hour with a really good stone or even longer. You have to be prepared for this and know that you’re going to spend a decent amount of time getting ready to cook your pizza before you’re ready to actually put it in the oven.

There are plenty of reasons that you’re going to want to get a pizza stone for yourself and your family. It’s definitely going to make your pizza’s taste a whole lot better and it’s going to make sure that you’re really getting good quality from something that you’ve put a lot of hard work and effort into. So make sure you’re really getting something that you’re going to enjoy and that you’re going to get the results you want from rather than just another pizza pan.


  1. Pizza Stones – Which Creates the Best Crust?