Best Cookie Sheet

Who doesn’t love doing some baking? Whether it’s cookies or cakes or anything else, you want to make sure that it looks great and tastes great at the same time, but of course, that means getting the right tools for the job.

One of the first tools that you need to get is a great quality cookie sheet. After all, that’s the only way you’re going to get those great treats to come out right and these are our favorites.

Missy Enders, Author, HESCA
Missy Enders

#1 AirBake Nonstick 2

View On Amazon


The AirBake Nonstick Pack is designed to help you get some great quality cookies and baked goods. It comes with two cookie sheets so you’re ready to really get some baking done and each one is a different size, so you can create different batches of treats. Because of the form of these cookie sheets they’re also intended to get your baked goods done in a lot less time.

These sheets don’t have edges like others, which means they’re not designed for your thinner items or cakes. Instead, they’re designed only to make your favorite cookies, scones and other sweet treats that come in a firmer dough. They’re also made with heavy-weight aluminized steel which is also air insulated to keep them from burning your treats.

The micro-dome shape of the sheets is so slight you don’t even notice but it’s also going to help you cook anything in a lot less time. You’ll also get a 10 year warranty and a non-stick sheet that means you’ll easily be able to get to your cookies when the timer goes off. On the edge is a slightly raised edge that makes it easier to get the cookies out when they’re done as well.

  • You’ll definitely be wanting more of these sheets when you see how great they are and just how much more they can do than your standard cookie sheets. These will very quickly become your favorites with everything that they can do for you.

#2 Nordic Ware Natural

View On Amazon


This cookie sheet is definitely a popular one and for a great reason, it’s very high quality. Made by a company that is very well known in the way of baking and cooking in general, this Nordic Ware sheet has a slight rise on each side to make it perfect even for thin cakes and other deserts as well as your favorite cookies.

The natural aluminum that the sheet is made with is designed to last forever without rusting, making sure that you are always able to make your favorite cookies without having to worry about buying a new cookie sheet. You’ll also have plenty of great quality heat conductivity and a sheet that is extremely resistant to any type of warming.

Though this sheet is not designed to go in the dishwasher, it is still extremely easy to clean and it comes in a variety of different sizes and even shapes so you can create any type of dessert you might want. You’ll be able to make a whole lot more than just cookies with sheets from Nordic Ware and they’re all great to purchase as well. That’s definitely going to help with any dessert you want.

These pans are all made in the United States, which is an added benefit and they are lightweight and easy to use. You’ll be able to use these for your own home or you can use them for commercial purposes as they are certified to a high grade. They’re guaranteed to bake everything evenly and provide a uniform amount of browning no matter what you make. You also don’t have to worry about your treats browning too much because the color of the pans actually helps prevent this.

  • With the large edge you can easily get the pans in and out of the oven safely and quickly so you don’t lose any of the heat or get burned. This also makes them safer for younger bakers as well.

#3 Wilton Recipe Right

View On Amazon


The Wilton Recipe Right Cookie Pan is a very inexpensive pan that allows you to make all of your favorite sweets and cookies with ease. You can easily pick up a couple and get all of your treats done quickly and just the way you want them to be. That’s because you’re going to have no problem getting a good quality heat all the way through.

These cookie sheets are designed with a heavy gauge so that you get a nice, even cooking temperature all the way through. You don’t have to worry about anything because they also have a non-stick surface that helps you get your food right back off the pan with no problems. You won’t have to worry about breaking your cookies or other treats prying them off.

  • With this pan you’ll also have an easy time cleaning because it’s designed to wipe right off. When you’re done with your cooking you can just swipe all the cookies off and wipe it down and you’ll be all ready to use it again.
  • There’s no scraping pieces off or trying to get out stains and burns. This sheet is a standard size and even features a large ridge that makes it easier for you to get it into and out of the oven. Get a perfect browning process on all of your foods with no problem when you use this pan.

Cookie Sheet Buyer’s Guide


Size Available

First you want to take a look at the sizes that are available for you when you’re choosing a new cookie sheet. Not all sheets are created equally, after all, and that means you could find yourself with something that is too small or too large for your purposes. You want to make sure you’re looking at everything available and that you’re choosing something you’re going to get the most use out of. Some people might do better with a large sheet that lets them cook a large quantity at the same time while others might prefer something that is smaller and lets them make a small batch. It’s up to you what size is going to work best but you definitely want to know what you’re looking for.


Nearly every cookie sheet you can find nowadays is going to be non-stick but you definitely want to make sure of that. You don’t want to be trying to cook something and realize that you should have greased the pan, after all. With the sheets we’ve talked about and most others you’re not going to have to worry about that because the pan will be coated and you’ll get everything off easily, but you want to make sure that’s addressed. Any pan that is non-stick will definitely tell you because it’s an important and added feature.

Easy to Clean

You definitely want to know how easy to clean your pan is going to be as well. Just because it’s non-stick you’re already going to be getting a little bit of a head start on the cleaning because nothing should stick, but that’s not going to be the only thing you want to look at. You want to check also if you’re able to use the pan in the dishwasher or if you need to clean it by hand. While this might not be a big problem for you either way, you want to make sure that you’re at least aware of what you’re going to get and how you’re going to have to clean it before that time actually comes.cookie-and-coffee

What’s it Made Of?

Finally, make sure you’re checking what your cookie sheet is actually made of. You don’t want something that’s made with lightweight or flimsy ingredients because you’ll end up breaking it or you’ll end up with unevenly baked cookies. A high quality aluminum is likely going to be your best bet, but be sure to look at some of the different materials that are out there. You might be surprised what all you can find as long as you’re looking for the best quality possible.

Cookie sheets are definitely going to get a lot of use if you’re the type of family that really likes sweets. The best thing to do, therefore, is to start looking for a cookie sheet that is going to help you make as many of those sweets as possible without you having to put a whole lot of work and effort into it. You want something that is going to stay clean and easy to use but also something that you’re going to be able to use over and over again without having to replace it. Look for different types of cookie sheets in different forms and find the right one, in the right size and configuration, that’s going to work for you. There are plenty of them out there after all. Why not get a few?


  1. Cookie Sheet Tip Sheet